Robots vs. Humans on Mars

Many people believe that it’s preferable to send robots to Mars instead of humans because it’s cheaper and doesn’t jeopardise human lives. However, if settlement is our aim – and it should be – we must send people. In fact, even if exploration and science are our only goals, we can still achieve much more with humans.

In recent years we’ve witnessed a number of tremendous successes with robotic exploration of Mars. This effort has moved us significantly forward in our scientific understanding of Mars, how sensors and actuators function on Mars, and how to land stuff on Mars. The Mars Exploration Rovers Spirit and Opportunity have been a fascinating triumph: with an initial planned mission duration of just 90 sols (a “sol” is a Martian day, about 24 hours and 40 minutes), Spirit lasted about seven years and Opportunity is still going strong and making discoveries after 10. The landing of the Curiosity rover in 2012 was also a spectacular achievement in terms of engineering, being the largest mass (900kg) ever soft-landed on Mars.

Although much can and has been achieved with robots, humans on Mars will achieve much more. Although robots may not require air, water and food, humans offer greater cognition, dexterity, flexibility, adaptability, creativity, independence and efficiency; at least for now. The robots we’ve sent to Mars are in fact semi-autonomous, remote-controlled machines, directed by people on Earth. Astronauts on the surface of Mars will be guided by experts on Earth, but they’ll also have the freedom to indulge their own curiosity, pursue individual interests, and organise their own time and activities to a large degree.

Whether humans or robots go to Mars, the goal is for humans to gain knowledge and experience of Mars. Robots are simply a tool to achieve this, and are therefore effectively the “middle-man”. But the middle-man can be removed in order to get a better result. With humans on Mars, the experience of Mars can be obtained more directly and much more efficiently.

Robotic exploration proceeds extremely slowly and cautiously, partly because of the time delay in communications, but partly because these machines cost millions or billions of dollars to develop and send to Mars, and are therefore designed to move very slowly to ensure their survival. Every action must be considered and approved by a team on Earth before being sent to the robot. Every instruction takes between four and 20 minutes to reach Mars, and every photo and piece of data collected takes at least the same amount of time to be sent back to Earth. These machines have limited cognitive and physical abilities; if one becomes stuck in soft soil, such as what happened to Spirit, sometimes nothing can be done to get them out.

Humans will also move cautiously on Mars, but they can still move a lot faster while being careful. They can do many more things, both cognitively and physically, they don’t have to wait for instructions from Earth for every little decision, they can react in real time to unexpected events or discoveries, and if they get stuck in soft soil (for example) they can figure out a solution themselves or one of their crewmates can help them. A group of co-operating humans is functionally equivalent to a group of networked bipedal dexterous robots with strong AI. Perhaps in 20 to 40 years we can send machines to be that; or, we can just send people now.

Humans on Mars will not only deliver new information about Mars, but also the experience of Mars. They’ll be able to communicate with people on Earth in a way that robots simply cannot; they’ll be able to share emotions and sensory experiences that robots can’t have. This empathy will engage humanity with the Martian adventure and bring Mars within the sphere of our collective experience. The gates of human imagination and ingenuity will open, stimulating a flood of new ideas, missions, projects, experiments, businesses and plans, leading us directly into our dream of becoming multiplanetary.

Robots will always be part of our life on Mars. But we must send people, to more rapidly increase our knowledge of Mars, to bring Mars within the human sphere, and to commence a process of settlement.


I like to read, write, teach, travel, code, lift weights, play music, listen to music, make things out of wood, watch scifi movies, and play board games and computer games. My interests are broad, spanning science, engineering, architecture, technology, nutrition, environment, psychology, health, fitness, finance, business, and economics, but my main passions are spirituality, space settlement, and veganism. My ambition is to be a successful writer and speaker, and to create a company to produce awesome science fiction books, movies, and games that inspire people about the future. Eventually, I would also like to create vegan cafes and urban farms.

Posted in Mars

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow Shaun's Blog on
Let’s connect!

You can reach me via any of the options below:

Email Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram YouTube Reddit Quora GoodReads Amazon
Read my book!

It's free to download or read online, and very good. If you're into Mars exploration, you will love it.

You can also buy the Kindle version or a print copy.

Watch my TEDx talk
%d bloggers like this: